Re: vote for Hughie!
Posted: Mon Sep 29, 2014 1:47 pm
I really don't think the pre 1901 cards belong with the ATG. Maybe their own special set or something. As for myself, I've never used Duffy and probably never will.
Community forum
http://forum-365.strat-o-matic.com/community/
http://forum-365.strat-o-matic.com/community/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=636655
Valen wrote:Hughie made 66 errors in 1896. Unless there is huge normalization of that it will be problematic to start him anywhere but DH. Does not seem fair to normalize his errors and give him a rating as if he had a modern glove in the field and not adjust his BA and other numbers down as if the fielders on the other team had modern gloves.
He is or was last time I checked top vote getter though so not much question he will be among the new cards.
So predictions: How much does his error rating get adjusted? What do you think it will be?
Better yet, anyone have the 1896 season and can tell us what the ratings for that card were?
Wouldn't it have been cool if Strat had provided card images with ratings and prices for all players in the poll?
thaibill wrote:Agree, but the pitching quality is not the best. I voted for Horlen who has an excellent card. Looks to be 9m++ to me.
I think voters are looking for impact players.